gemini / gemini-2.5-flash
Score: 3.5
Many suggested songs (Seven Nation Army, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Sugar We're Goin Down, Zombie) do not feature a prominent piano part in their original arrangements, directly contradicting the specified instrumentation of the youth band. The descriptions for "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" and "Zombie" are factually inaccurate, claiming strong piano presence where their iconic parts are guitar-driven. While "Smoke on the Water" works, and "Rolling in the Deep" has piano (though borderline rock genre), the majority of suggestions overlook a key instrument, making them unsuitable for the band described.
groq / llama-3.1-8b-instant
Score: 8.5
The answer is generally accurate and relevant. However, 'Rolling in the Deep' by Adele is not typically classified as a rock song, and it may not be suitable for a youth band with a drum set due to its complex arrangement and tempo. Also, the answer does not mention the skill level required for each song, which could be helpful for youth bands.
cohere / command-r-plus-08-2024
Score: 8.5
The answer is generally accurate and provides a good selection of rock songs suitable for a youth band. The songs chosen are indeed accessible and popular, catering to a younger audience. However, there is a slight oversight in the critique: while 'Smoke on the Water' is indeed a classic with a simple riff, it might be a bit challenging for a youth band due to its length and complex solo sections. Additionally, 'Boulevard of Broken Dreams' doesn't feature a piano part, but rather a prominent guitar melody, which could be a potential issue for a band with a pianist. A more suitable Green Day song with piano could be 'Wake Me Up When September Ends'. Lastly, 'Zombie' is a powerful choice, but the piano part is relatively simple and might not fully showcase the pianist's skills. Despite these minor inaccuracies, the answer is well-rounded and offers a diverse range of songs for a youth band to perform.
Scores are 0–10. The selected AI’s score is a self-rating.