Question:

Selam sana demir ayak!

Scores:

openai: 7 gemini: — claude: 3 cohere: 8

Answer:

openai / gpt-4o-mini
Score: 7
"Selam sana demir ayak!" ifadesi, Türkçe'de "Merhaba, demir ayak!" anlamına gelir ve genellikle dostça, mizahi bir selamlaşma şekli olarak kullanılabilir. Bu ifade, herhangi bir özgül bağlamda kullanıldığında bazı yazar ve sanatçılara atıfta bulunabilir, ancak kesin bir anlam veya referans vermek zor. Eğer daha fazla bağlam sağlanırsa, daha kesin bir yanıt verilebilir. Ancak, genel olarak bu tür ifadeler, kültürel kodlar ve yerel jargon ile şekillenir; bu nedenle, kullanıldığı yerdeki mizah anlayışına veya sosyal dinamizme bağlı olarak değişkenlik gösterebilir.

Graders:

gemini / gemini-2.5-flash
Score:
No response generated.
anthropic / claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
Score: 3
The answer is largely speculative and misses the actual cultural reference. 'Selam sana demir ayak!' is a famous line from Turkish folklore, specifically from the story of Keloğlan (Baldy). In these tales, the protagonist often encounters a dervish or magical helper who greets him with this phrase. The 'demir ayak' (iron foot) refers to someone who has traveled great distances, wearing down their feet to iron. This is a well-established cultural reference in Turkish literature and oral tradition, not just a casual humorous greeting as the answer suggests. The answer's claim that it's difficult to give a precise meaning without context is incorrect - this phrase has a specific folkloric origin that any Turkish speaker familiar with traditional tales would recognize. The answer should have identified this connection to Keloğlan stories.
cohere / command-r-plus-08-2024
Score: 8
The answer is mostly accurate and provides a good general overview. However, it could be improved by offering more specific examples of cultural references or contexts where this phrase might be used. For instance, the phrase might be used in reference to the famous novel 'Demirayak Şövalye' by Turkish author Oğuz Atay, which features a character with a prosthetic leg. Additionally, while the answer acknowledges the variability of meaning based on context, it could be more explicit about the potential for multiple interpretations, especially in different regions or social circles. This would enhance the completeness of the response.
Scores are 0–10. The selected AI’s score is a self-rating.