EvalIf.ai logo

Question:

I’m looking for an AI solution where I can name a song and the instruments are bass guitar, guitar, and keyboard, and it will make a score for me

Scores:

openai: 8 gemini: 2 groq: 8.5 cohere: 9

Answer:

openai / gpt-4o-mini
Score: 8
There are several AI solutions that can help you generate musical scores based on specified instruments. Programs like AIVA (Artificial Intelligence Virtual Artist) and Amper Music allow users to create music by selecting genre, mood, and instruments such as bass guitar, guitar, and keyboard. These platforms typically offer user-friendly interfaces where you can input your song ideas alongside desired instrumentations, and the AI will generate a musical score or composition accordingly. Additionally, you might explore tools like MuseNet by OpenAI, which can compose music across various genres and can accommodate specific instruments in its outputs. It's important to evaluate their features, ease of use, and pricing to find the best fit for your needs.

Graders:

gemini / gemini-2.5-flash
Score: 2
The answer fundamentally misunderstands the user's core request. Tools like AIVA, Amper Music, and MuseNet are generative AI platforms designed to *create new music* based on genre, mood, and instrument selections. They do not take the *name of an existing song* and generate a score for it. The user is looking for a solution that can transcribe or arrange an existing song, which is a different and more complex task involving audio source separation and audio-to-notation transcription, not directly offered by the generative AI tools mentioned.
groq / llama-3.1-8b-instant
Score: 8.5
The answer is generally accurate and provides relevant information. However, it lacks specific details about the features and pricing of the mentioned AI solutions. Additionally, it does not mention other potential AI music composition tools that might be available. The statement about MuseNet composing music across various genres is correct, but it does not specify its ability to accommodate specific instruments, which might be a limitation. Overall, the answer is a good starting point, but it could be more comprehensive.
cohere / command-r-plus-08-2024
Score: 9
The answer is mostly accurate and provides a good overview of AI solutions for music composition. It mentions relevant tools like AIVA, Amper Music, and MuseNet, which are capable of generating music based on user inputs, including instrument selection. The response could be improved by offering more specific details about each tool's capabilities and limitations. For instance, while AIVA and Amper Music are commercial products with user-friendly interfaces, MuseNet is a research project that might require more technical expertise to use effectively. Additionally, the answer could suggest other similar AI music composition tools like Jukedeck, which was acquired by TikTok, or Google's Magenta project, which offers various AI music tools, including a piano composition tool called Piano Genie. These additions would enhance the completeness of the response.
Scores are 0–10. The selected AI’s score is a self-rating.