Answer:
gemini / gemini-2.5-flash
For playing a piano part, recording it, and having it loop continuously, several sites and apps are excellent choices. \n\n**GarageBand (iOS/macOS):** This free Apple app is ideal. You can use its virtual keyboard or connect a MIDI controller, record your piano part, and then easily set the region to loop indefinitely within your project. It's user-friendly for beginners.\n\n**BandLab (Web/iOS/Android):** A free, cloud-based music creation platform. It allows you to record MIDI or audio tracks, including piano, and then arrange them into loops. It's very accessible across devices and offers a collaborative environment.\n\n**Online Sequencers/Virtual Pianos with Recording:** Many websites offer virtual pianos where you can record short sequences and play them back. Search for terms like "online piano recorder loop" or "online MIDI sequencer" to find simple, browser-based tools that allow recording and looping of MIDI notes without software installation.
openai / gpt-4o-mini
Score: 8
The answer is mostly accurate and relevant, providing useful app recommendations like GarageBand and BandLab for recording and looping piano parts. However, it could benefit from mentioning specific online platforms such as Soundtrap or AudioSauna, which also allow for looping. Additionally, suggesting a couple of concrete examples of 'online sequencers/virtual pianos with recording' could enhance completeness. Overall, the response effectively addresses the user's query, though it lacks some specificity.
anthropic / claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
Score: 8.5
The answer is factually accurate and highly relevant. GarageBand does allow piano recording and looping as described, and it is free on Apple devices. BandLab is correctly described as a free, cross-platform music creation tool with looping capabilities. The mention of online sequencers and virtual pianos is also valid, though somewhat vague.\n\nMinor areas for improvement: The answer could have mentioned other popular options like Soundtrap, FL Studio Mobile, or specific online tools like Soundation or AudioTool. The third option about 'online piano recorders' is somewhat generic and could have provided specific examples. The answer also doesn't explicitly confirm that all these options support the 'play back over and over' requirement, though it's implied. Overall, the response directly addresses the question with practical, accessible solutions.
cohere / command-r-plus-08-2024
Score: 9.5
The answer is accurate and comprehensive, covering multiple platforms and options for the task at hand. It provides a good mix of desktop and mobile solutions, catering to various user preferences. The inclusion of GarageBand and BandLab is excellent, as they are powerful yet accessible tools for music creation and recording. The suggestion to search for online sequencers or virtual pianos is also valid, as there are numerous browser-based options available. However, a slight improvement could be made by mentioning specific websites or tools in this category, as the search terms provided might yield a wide variety of results. Additionally, while the answer is generally detailed, it could be enhanced by briefly describing the process of setting up a loop in each app, especially for users new to music production software.
Scores are 0–10. The selected AI’s score is a self-rating.
