Question:

Is it possible to build a stock trading strategy using an AI model?

Scores:

gemini: 9.5 openai: 9 anthropic: 9 cohere: 9.5

Answer:

gemini / gemini-2.5-flash
Score: 9.5
Yes, it is absolutely possible and already widely implemented. AI and machine learning models are extensively used in quantitative finance to develop and execute stock trading strategies. These models can analyze vast datasets, including historical price data, trading volumes, economic indicators, company fundamentals, news sentiment, and even social media trends, to identify complex patterns and make predictions. \n\nCommon applications include predicting future stock prices, optimizing portfolio allocation, identifying arbitrage opportunities, and executing high-frequency trades. Techniques range from supervised learning for price forecasting to reinforcement learning for optimal trading decisions. While challenges like market volatility, data quality, overfitting, and the "black box" nature of some models exist, many institutional investors and hedge funds successfully employ AI-driven strategies to gain a competitive edge.

Graders:

openai / gpt-4o-mini
Score: 9
The answer accurately states that AI models are used in stock trading strategies and highlights various applications. It discusses the ability of AI to analyze multifaceted data sources and mentions both supervised and reinforcement learning techniques, which are relevant. However, it could emphasize the risks associated with algorithmic trading due to market unpredictability and the potential for models to fail. Additionally, mentioning that not all AI strategies guarantee success would provide a more balanced view. Overall, the response is comprehensive and informative.
anthropic / claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
Score: 9
The answer is factually accurate, comprehensive, and highly relevant. It correctly identifies that AI models are widely used in trading, mentions appropriate data sources (price data, fundamentals, sentiment, social media), and names legitimate applications (price prediction, portfolio optimization, arbitrage, HFT). The mention of both supervised and reinforcement learning is appropriate. The acknowledgment of challenges like overfitting, data quality, and model opacity is balanced and accurate.\n\nMinor limitation: The answer could briefly note that while AI can identify patterns and provide insights, consistent alpha generation remains extremely difficult due to market efficiency, and many AI trading strategies fail or underperform. The phrasing 'successfully employ' might slightly overstate the reliability of these strategies, as profitability is never guaranteed even with sophisticated AI models. Otherwise, this is an excellent response.
cohere / command-r-plus-08-2024
Score: 9.5
The answer is highly accurate and comprehensive, covering the key aspects of AI's role in stock trading strategies. It provides a clear overview of the applications, techniques, and challenges associated with AI-driven trading. The only minor improvement could be a brief mention of the ethical considerations and regulatory challenges that arise with AI in finance, especially concerning high-frequency trading and market manipulation. Additionally, while the answer is generally well-rounded, it might be worth noting that the success of AI models in stock trading is not universally guaranteed and depends on various factors, including the specific market, the quality of data, and the model's design and implementation.
Scores are 0–10. The selected AI’s score is a self-rating.