Answer:
gemini / gemini-2.5-flash
Based on "Rock Lobster," "Buddy Holly," and "Copacabana," your band enjoys a diverse mix of New Wave, alternative rock, and pop with prominent keyboard parts. Here are five more recommendations that leverage your instrumentation and offer a fun, recognizable repertoire: 1. **Don't Stop Believin' (Journey):** A classic rock anthem with iconic keyboard, strong guitar, bass, and drums, perfect for a big singalong. 2. **Mr. Brightside (The Killers):** A modern indie rock staple featuring a memorable synth riff, driving guitar, bass, and drums, popular with younger audiences. 3. **Sweet Dreams (Are Made of This) (Eurythmics):** An iconic synth-pop track with a distinctive keyboard hook, solid bassline, and adaptable guitar parts, fitting your New Wave interest. 4. **Stacy's Mom (Fountains of Wayne):** A catchy power-pop song with great guitar riffs, a solid rhythm section, and opportunities for keyboard texture, similar to Weezer's style. 5. **Walking on Sunshine (Katrina & The Waves):** An…
openai / gpt-4o-mini
Score: 9
The answer correctly identifies the band's preferences and suggests songs that align well with their style. Each recommendation includes recognizable tracks that suit the instrumentation of guitar, bass, keyboard, and drums. However, the answer could be improved by ensuring all songs maintain a consistent connection to the genres of New Wave, alternative rock, and pop. While 'Walking on Sunshine' is upbeat, it strays more towards a pop-rock sound without the same stylistic depth as the others. Additionally, expanding the variety by including a broader range of bands or styles might encourage further exploration for the teenage band.
anthropic / claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
Score: 9
The answer is factually accurate, complete, and highly relevant. All five recommended songs are real, well-known tracks that match the instrumentation (guitar, bass, keyboard, drums) and align well with the eclectic style established by the three initial songs. The reasoning for each selection is sound - they all feature prominent keyboard/synth parts and would be appropriate for a teenage band. The answer correctly identifies genres and key musical elements of each song. The only minor issue is that 'Walking on Sunshine' description appears to be cut off mid-sentence, making the answer technically incomplete. However, the truncation doesn't affect the validity of the recommendation itself or the other four complete suggestions. Overall, this is a well-crafted, accurate, and useful response to the question.
cohere / command-r-plus-08-2024
Score: 9.5
The answer is well-structured and provides a thoughtful selection of songs that align with the band's chosen repertoire. The songs recommended are indeed recognizable, fun, and showcase the band's instrumentation effectively. The critique is minor, as the answer could be improved by suggesting songs that are slightly more challenging for the band members, especially considering their interest in New Wave and alternative rock. For instance, 'Take On Me' by A-ha is a New Wave classic with a catchy keyboard riff and intricate guitar work that would test the band's skills. Additionally, 'Under Pressure' by Queen and David Bowie is a powerful rock duet with dynamic keyboard and drum parts, offering a more complex arrangement. These additions would provide a more comprehensive and progressive learning curve for the band while still adhering to their musical preferences.
Scores are 0–10. The selected AI’s score is a self-rating.
